“I can’t leave Substack, the alternatives charge monthly fees!”
For a mid-sized paid newsletter, you will pay:
Ghost Pro: $149–$269/month
Beehiiv: $131–$218/month
Buttondown: $239/month
Mailchimp: $285/month
Substack: $700/month
(this is based on assumptions of 20,000 members, 7% paid at $5/mo. twiddle the math as you see fit)
Cheapest option is self-hosting, though of course there is added time cost and a technical barrier to entry. I pay $100–$150/mo to self-host Ghost with a bit over 25,000 subscribers.
For free newsletters, Beehiiv is free for up to 2,500 subscribers. ConvertKit is free up to 10,000.
Adding to this thread because a bunch of people are asking: newsletters are expensive to run because of mailsending, not because of hosting costs. ~70% of my cost is for bulk email. A plain old static blog can be hosted for a couple bucks a month.
For those who aren’t a fan of my 20,000 number, here’s a breakdown:
(edited to fix an error in self-hosted ghost for 50k subs)
@molly0xfff Wow - I love people who can whip a table like that like it's nothing. Always takes me hours to get everything right...
Probably stupid question: why is the self-hosting Ghost quintupling in price between 50k and 100k subscribers? What is the step taken?
@ineiti @molly0xfff ghost pro isn't self-hosting, it's a company's managed hosting option
@simrob no, ineiti’s question is indeed about the self hosted version, and I was wondering the same
@GuillaumeRossolini @ineiti @molly0xfff oh, my apologies. Molly alluded to this: anywhere you're hosting from is almost certain to block outgoing emails, so you have to use a separate email delivery service like Mailgun. That's probably the vast majority of her expense.
@simrob it is, she’s said 70%, but that doesn’t explain the jump in cost from 50k subs to 100k, it isn’t linear
@GuillaumeRossolini @simrob yeah, it’s the mailsending (and an error in my math, now fixed)
25k subs ≈ 100,000 emails/mo: $75
50k subs ≈ 200,000 emails/mo: $205
100k subs ≈ 400,000 emails/mo: $400
@molly0xfff @simrob oh, right! Four+ weeks per month, of course
@GuillaumeRossolini @molly0xfff @simrob
and minor misprint (100 K for 200K), but nothing changes.
... It made me enlarge the image though, just to see.